Chapter 4 of 12
A Bitter Turn
2.8k words
A cool, unwavering composure was Julian Finch’s shield. Life, a meticulous exercise in self-regulation, had forged it within him. He harbored a profound aversion to displaying any hint of vulnerability, a silent vow against revealing the raw edges of his soul. Thus, even when faced with the most turbulent tides of emotion, he could navigate them with an almost unnerving serenity.
This quiet reserve often led others to label him insipid, a fellow devoid of fire. They mistook his stillness for apathy. The truth was far more complex: every emotional tempest Julian had weathered had, in turn, hardened the shell around him. Over years, it had become nearly impenetrable, leaving him untouched by the trivial vexations that stirred his peers.
This trait, he knew, was his passport. It allowed him to hover on the fringes of Alistair Thorne’s orbit, a precarious but vital position. Julian was a student of adequate merit, his artistic promise acknowledged by the professors, if not yet by the wider art world. His standing at the Academy, though humble, was one he had painstakingly carved out for himself. He clung to it with the tenacity of a drowning man.
“Finch!” Alistair’s voice, a casual whipcrack, cut through the clamour of the Great Hall.
Julian’s shoulders did not tense. He merely inclined his head, a gesture of quiet acknowledgement.
“That tone, Finch,” Alistair sneered, his lips curling with practiced disdain. “It’s enough to curdle milk.”
Julian’s gaze met Alistair’s, unwavering. A faint tremor stirred beneath his ribs, a familiar phantom ache. He offered no retort, knowing any spoken word would only lend Alistair more leverage. His face, a canvas of studied neutrality, revealed nothing.
“Still painting those morose still lifes, are you? Always so serious.” Alistair’s eyes, glinting with malicious amusement, drifted across the hall. “Tell me, Finch, do you never notice anything… prettier?”
Alistair was a creature of raw impulse, crude and thoughtless in his appetites. Since puberty, he had been a slave to his baser urges, his desires thinly veiled by a veneer of aristocratic privilege. His attention, Julian noted with a sickening lurch, had settled on a familiar, slight figure at the far end of the hall. Thomas Atherton, the new scholarship student.
Julian’s stomach tightened. A profound, empathetic dread, cold as river ice, settled in his gut.
---
August, the twilight of summer break, found Thomas Atherton already a ghost. He moved through the gilded halls of the Academy, his head bowed, a palpable aura of isolation clinging to him. Alistair Thorne, however, seemed far from satisfied with this quiet devastation. His cruelty, Julian knew, lacked the subtlety of restraint. It grew more blatant with each passing day.
Alistair’s immediate hangers-on—the boorish Lestrade, the oafish Crowley, and the sneering Bellamy—would linger after the morning lectures, waiting for their master. Other students, the more respectable sons of merchants and minor gentry from the West Wing, would scuttle out the moment the bell for the luncheon promenade sounded, keen to escape the magnetic pull of Alistair’s toxic presence.
Julian, once, had been part of Alistair’s inner orbit. In his first year, fresh-faced and eager for acceptance, he had pursued the friendship of the more prominent students, however ill-chosen. By his second year, a quiet shift occurred. “Finch is too fastidious,” Crowley had once remarked, a careless dismissal. “He frets over every brushstroke as if it were a declaration of war. We’re always late for billiards because of him.”
Without a word from Julian, he was subtly but definitively excluded. The most galling part? Alistair had not cared. Julian’s presence or absence was of no consequence to him.
A bitter taste, sharp and acrid, filled Julian’s mouth. He found himself glancing at Alistair, then away. “Am I truly so… particular?” he murmured, the words barely audible, a testament to his wounded pride. The question, Julian knew, was not for Alistair, but for the invisible tribunal within his own mind.
“Of course you are,” Bellamy had scoffed. “You chew on your ideas like a cow, while the rest of us are off to the races. We’ve a wager with the lads from the next atelier today. Go eat with Blackwood.”
Julian had swallowed his pride. It had been a choice between clinging to a group that scorned him or accepting a quieter, less humiliating arrangement. Besides, the chronic indigestion that had plagued him through his first year, a knot of anxiety in his stomach, was surely a consequence of rushing his artistic studies to keep pace with Alistair’s endless demands. The thought of clinging to Alistair’s coat-tails like a discarded husk disgusted him even more than his quiet banishment.
He had not pleaded. He had not protested.
And just like that, he was out of the immediate fold. His own will, his own desires, had mattered little in the grand scheme of social manoeuvre.
Trying to project an air of nonchalant indifference, Julian had found his eyes meeting those of Silas Blackwood. Silas, perched atop a stool, meticulously sharpening a stick of charcoal, had glanced at Julian, his dark eyes assessing, before returning to his task. “Will you be eating, Finch?” he asked, his voice even, devoid of inflection.
Julian hesitated. “Yes,” he said, the word feeling oddly brittle. “Soon.”
“I generally take my meal in ten minutes,” Silas offered, without looking up.
“Yes,” Julian repeated, a fraction too quickly. “That works for me too.”
In truth, Julian had never eaten at such a late hour. But a primal survival instinct asserted itself. If he wished to maintain any semblance of position, even alongside the notoriously solitary Silas, he had to adapt. That first luncheon alone with Silas, Julian had left half his mutton untouched, feigning a sudden lack of appetite.
Silas had raised a perfectly sculpted eyebrow. “Are you still so particular, Finch? A man of eighteen years?”
Julian had bristled. “What business is it of yours?”
“Only an observation,” Silas had replied, his gaze returning to his sketching. “A man cannot paint with a rumbling stomach.”
“Even adults prefer their fish without such an unctuous sauce,” Julian had retorted, the petulance surprising even himself. Silas had merely hummed, a low, dismissive sound that grated on Julian’s nerves.
In his first year, Julian and Alistair had been near inseparable, for all Alistair’s casual cruelty. By the second, those shared moments had dwindled. It was not entirely Silas’s doing, but his presence, his sheer academic and artistic gravitas, created a counter-weight that subtly shifted the Academy’s social currents. Julian had no right to complain. Silas Blackwood, a prodigy in his own right, outranked Julian in every conceivable measure of merit.
Silas’s circle, or rather, the space around him that others dared not intrude, consisted primarily of serious students, the ones who would spend hours in the atelier, their hands smudged with paint and charcoal. They were the antithesis of Alistair’s boisterous, often disruptive coterie. Yet, Alistair, mindful of his family’s reputation and the Dean’s watchful eye, generally remained within the Academy’s official schedule.
Julian had once asked Silas why he tolerated the constant noise, the casual vulgarity that often emanated from Alistair’s group in the shared lecture halls. Silas had stopped sketching, his dark eyes sharp.
“Do you truly believe me so lacking in discernment, Finch?”
“No, but… your peers often indulge in such folly.”
“Peers?” Silas had scoffed, a rare display of open disdain. “They are not my peers. They are an unfortunate distraction.”
“What?” Julian had asked, surprised by the vehemence.
“A student’s duty is to attend his lessons, to cultivate his mind, to master his craft. Is that not so, Finch?”
“That is true, of course.”
“Then do not insult me by lumping me with such… dross. It offends my sensibilities.”
“Forgive me.”
“I was not seeking an apology. Merely clarity.”
The statement was logical, impeccable, yet hearing it from Silas Blackwood felt strangely absurd. This was the same youth whose brilliance often seemed to draw the very attention he claimed to despise.
Regardless, Julian had found himself spending most of his second year in this strange, liminal space—flanking Alistair Thorne, but also gravitating towards Silas Blackwood. He considered it a sacred space, a delicate equilibrium that no one else could intrude upon. It would have been simpler, perhaps, without Silas, yet, surprisingly, they had forged a peculiar understanding. Julian did not like Silas, but he was not so intolerable that Julian would flee his quiet company. He was merely… irritatingly brilliant.
But Thomas Atherton, poor, timid Thomas, had turned even those days into a waking nightmare.
---
Today felt subtly different.
“Damn it. Lestrade and Crowley, those bastards,” Alistair cursed, running a hand through his perfectly coiffed hair as the fourth period neared its close. His voice, usually so self-assured, held an uncharacteristic note of irritation.
Hearing his voice, Julian turned immediately, a flicker of anticipation, both hopeful and dread-filled, stirring within him. “They’ve absconded again?” he asked, his tone carefully neutral.
“Fucking idiots.” Alistair slammed a book shut.
“How inconvenient,” Julian offered. “With whom will you take your luncheon, then?” He could not help the sudden, nervous tremble in his fingers as he gripped the back of his chair.
Alistair let out a heavy sigh, his gaze sweeping over the near-empty classroom before settling on Silas, who was meticulously cleaning his brushes. “Blackwood. I’ll be joining you two today.”
Silas did not look up. “Do not presume. You were not invited.” His voice, though quiet, carried an edge of cold dismissal.
“Keep that insolent tongue wagging, Blackwood, and I’ll have it cut out,” Alistair retorted, his eyes narrowing.
Silas finally met Alistair’s gaze, his own expression one of detached annoyance. “Good heavens, Thorne, today truly makes me wish to commit an act of physical violence upon your person.”
“Go ahead and try, you academic dullard.”
“Such bluster for a fellow who would otherwise dine alone.”
Julian could hold back no longer. He pushed himself to his feet. “Come now,” he interjected, his voice carefully modulated, desperate to smooth over the escalating tension. “Let us all take our meal together. We cannot leave Thorne to dine alone.”
His desperation must have been evident, a raw nerve exposed. Alistair smirked triumphantly, casting a sly, knowing glance at Silas. “See? I have excellent companions.”
Silas merely scowled, sweeping Alistair’s misplaced paint tin from the desk with a casual flick of his wrist. It clattered to the floor with a metallic ring. Whether Silas liked Julian or not mattered little at that moment. What mattered was that Alistair had agreed to join them for lunch.
It had been so long since they had truly shared a meal, a fragile illusion of camaraderie. Julian found himself so thrilled, so desperate for this fleeting validation, that he even forced himself to swallow the cloyingly sweet jellied eels, a dish he loathed.
But Alistair paid little mind to his food. His eyes, sharp and restless, scanned the busy cafeteria like a predator searching for prey. Julian, too consumed with the precarious joy of Alistair’s presence, barely noticed Silas calmly pilfering a selection of his pickled gherkins. Then, without warning, Alistair’s fork clattered to his plate. His free hand shot out, seizing the arm of someone passing by their table.
Looking up, Julian saw it was Thomas Atherton. Thomas’s eyes, wide with fright, met Julian’s for a fleeting instant.
“Sit here,” Alistair commanded, nodding towards the empty seat beside him, directly opposite Julian. “You had no one else to eat with, did you?”
Thomas’s face flushed a vivid scarlet. His gaze darted, settling briefly on Julian, a silent plea in his wide eyes. He bit his lip, then slowly, reluctantly, sank into the proffered seat.
Julian felt a cold shock. Stunned. Dumbfounded. Since when did Alistair Thorne care about Thomas Atherton’s company? And the very reason Thomas sat alone, isolated and vulnerable, was entirely Alistair’s doing. Alistair actively disliked anyone showing the slightest warmth towards Thomas.
A bitter, metallic taste rose in Julian’s throat.
Unconsciously, his spoon clattered against his pewter tray, the sound unnaturally loud in the bustling room. Only Thomas reacted, flinching visibly, his eyes darting to Julian in renewed apprehension. Alistair, however, remained fixated on Thomas, a cruel glint in his eyes.
Damn it. At that moment, the protective shell Julian had so painstakingly constructed over the years began to crack. He tried to halt the rupture, but it was beyond his control. Perhaps he was nearing a breaking point he hadn’t known existed.
Desperately clinging to denial, Julian snapped at Thomas. “Atherton. Leave now.”
“H-huh?” Thomas stammered, his small shoulders hunching.
“Do not listen to Thorne. Just go. It is perfectly fine.”
“Finch,” Alistair said, his voice dropping to a dangerously low growl. The casual threat in his tone was unmistakable.
When Julian told Thomas he could leave, Alistair, who had ignored the jarring clang of the spoon, finally ground his teeth, his eyes boring into Julian with murderous intent. That glare, rather than cowing Julian, only strengthened his resolve. He fixed his own gaze stubbornly on Thomas.
“I will handle this. You are free to depart.”
“Uh, o-okay.” Thomas began to push back from the table.
“And Thorne,” Julian continued, addressing Alistair directly, “cease this charade at once.”
“Yes, I believe so too,” Silas chimed in, through a mouthful of pickled gherkin, his words muffled but clear. His sudden interjection felt strangely out of place, almost absurd. He chewed and swallowed with deliberate slowness, then glanced between Julian and Alistair, a faint, irritating smirk playing on his lips. “Your theatrical display is quite inimical to my digestion.”
As always, Silas’s unnecessary provocations grated on Julian’s nerves. The man was insufferable, no matter how one regarded him. Ignoring Silas, Julian turned back to Alistair.
“Leave Atherton alone.”
“Who in God’s name are you to dictate my actions?” Alistair shot back, his face contorting with fury.
“It is tiresome for the rest of us to witness,” Julian replied, his voice calm despite the tremor in his hands beneath the table.
Julian did not blink, meeting Alistair’s furious stare. Alistair slammed his fist on the table. The sudden impact made Thomas, who was hovering uncertainly, flinch and squeeze his eyes shut. Silas, on the other hand, merely chuckled, a low, languid sound, raising a hand as if in ironic surrender.
“Count me out of this vulgar dispute.” He dabbed a napkin to his lips. “Let us resolve this by a simple matter of consensus. I remain neutral. Finch wishes him gone. Thorne insists he stays.”
Silas was one of the few who referred to Julian by his surname rather than the familiar ‘Finch,’ a small but significant detail that always pricked Julian’s pride. That irritation, a subtle inflection of his tightly controlled anger, slipped out now. “Do not interject yourself. Your vote holds no weight.”
“Why ever not? There is another party directly involved.” Silas, unfazed, smirked and pointed a precise finger at Thomas, a casual, almost indifferent gesture. “What? Is Atherton not a person with a will of his own?”
“You are incorrigible.”
“Why is he silent? Allow him to speak his desires.”
As if Thomas could possibly speak in this tension-filled atmosphere. Julian sighed at Silas’s thoughtless antics, picking up his spoon and idly stirring his rice pudding. It was then that Alistair tapped a manicured finger on the table, a chilling staccato.
“If you leave this table, Atherton, you will be irrevocably ruined, starting this very hour.”
Tears began to well in Thomas’s large, brown eyes, which glimmered as he looked at Julian, a desperate plea for succour. Damn it. Julian pressed his lips together, his jaw aching with the effort of control.
“It is fine. I will prevent him,” Julian said, attempting to infuse his voice with a reassurance he did not feel.
“Finch,” Alistair growled, his voice tight with barely suppressed rage.
Julian forced himself to meet Alistair’s gaze, pretending to be utterly unperturbed. He felt an overwhelming urge to break down, to flee. To suppress it, he looked up at the intricate ceiling for a moment, tracing the patterns of the plasterwork, before lowering his head and replying nonchalantly. “Yes?”
“You…” Alistair clenched his fist, glaring at Julian with an intensity that felt like a searing brand. Still, Julian had to endure it. His instincts screamed that he could not abandon Thomas to Alistair’s cruel mercies.
But Alistair’s focus shifted back to Thomas, whose small frame trembled.
“I-I will go,” Thomas stammered, his voice thin and reedy.
Thomas glanced at Julian one last time, a flicker of gratitude in his tear-filled eyes. “Th-thank you, Finch.” He pushed back from the table with a sudden, jerky movement, turning to flee. His footsteps were unsteady, almost a shuffle, as he hurried away.
As soon as Thomas was gone, Alistair turned abruptly, his glare, now fully unleashed, settling entirely on Julian.