Chapter 3 of 14
Chapter 3: Breadcrumbs
1.3k words
Twenty-eight minutes later, the bell above the door of Miller’s Diner jingled sharply.
Marcus walked in looking like he had sprinted across the quad, his heavy canvas messenger bag slung over one shoulder and his jaw set in a tight, protective line. His eyes scanned the dimly lit room until they landed on the corner booth—and stopped dead when he saw Sophie sitting across from Jack.
Jack raised two fingers in a quiet wave.
Marcus strode over, his expression shifting from fierce readiness to momentary confusion before sliding into the booth beside Jack. He looked across the table at Sophie—taking in the oversized sweater, the faint red rims around her eyes, and the half-eaten plate of food—then glanced sideways at Jack.
"Okay," Marcus said, lowering his voice as he pulled a sleek black laptop from his bag and flipped it open. "Fill me in. Who's this, and what did I miss?"
"Marcus, this is Sophie," Jack said evenly, resting an arm along the back of the vinyl seat. "Sophie, my roommate, Marcus. And to answer your question—she's the reason I know Jessica wasn't at the library Tuesday night. She's been dating the guy Jessica's been sneaking around with."
Marcus froze, his fingers hovering over the trackpad. Slowly, he looked back at Sophie, the sharp skepticism in his eyes melting instantly into genuine sympathy. "Damn. I'm sorry, Sophie. Seriously."
Sophie offered a small, hesitant nod, tucking a strand of dark hair behind her ear. "Thank you. And... thank you for coming to help."
"Are you kidding? I've been waiting three months for a reason to expose Jessica," Marcus muttered, plugging a small drive into the side of his laptop. "Alright. Show me what you've got so far."
Sophie unlocked her phone and slid it across the table. Marcus scrolled through the photos—the walk downtown, the kiss in the alley, the neon sign of the off-campus hotel—his brow furrowing deeper with every swipe.
"Amateur hour," Marcus breathed, shaking his head in disgust. "They didn't even bother going to the next town over. Give me five minutes with the metadata on these timestamps and whatever public digital footprint they left behind."
As Marcus’s fingers began flying across the mechanical keys, the booth fell into a quiet hum. Sophie watched the screen reflect in Marcus’s glasses, her posture tensing again as reality crept back into the corners of the diner.
Noticing her fingers twisting tightly in the hem of her sweater, Jack reached across the table and gently tapped the back of her hand to catch her attention.
"Hey," Jack murmured softly, waiting until she met his eyes. "Take a breath. You don't have to watch the screen."
Sophie let out a slow, shaky exhale, the tension in her shoulders easing just a fraction under his steady gaze.
"Got a hit," Marcus announced ten minutes later, turning the laptop slightly so they could both see. "Jessica's Venmo transactions are still set to public—rookie mistake. Look at the dates. Every single Tuesday and Thursday night she claimed to be at 'student council prep' for the past two months, she split an Uber or a late-night food order with an account named Cole_M."
Sophie stared at the screen, her chest tightening painfully. "Two months..."
"It goes back even further on Instagram," Marcus added grimly, pulling up a secondary window showing archived comment threads and tagged location check-ins from local bars and coffee shops. "They started getting sloppy around the end of September. Same timestamps, same neighborhoods, right when both of them supposedly started 'working late.'"
Jack stared at the glowing screen, that familiar, numbing cold spreading quietly behind his ribs. Two months of forehead kisses, two months of "I'm so exhausted from studying, babe," two months of him letting her sleep in while he quietly made her breakfast. Every memory felt suddenly hollow, like a photograph left out in the sun until all the color bled away.
He didn't flinch. He didn't clench his fists. He simply reached into his pocket, pulled out his notebook, and began writing down the dates in neat, calm handwriting.
Across the table, Sophie watched the subtle tightening at the corner of Jack’s jaw. Even though he kept his voice completely level, she could feel the sheer weight pressing down on his shoulders—and it made her chest ache worse than seeing Cole’s name on the screen.
"There's one more problem," Sophie said quietly, pulling her gaze away from Jack to look at Marcus. "Cole isn't just careless. When he gets cornered, he gets... possessive. If he finds out I'm digging into this before we're ready, he'll show up at my dorm."
"Then you're not walking across campus alone," Jack said immediately, his tone dropping into a quiet, non-negotiable firmness that made Sophie look up in surprise. "Not between classes, and definitely not at night."
"He's right," Marcus chimed in, closing his laptop with a soft click. "Do you have a roommate or someone in your building you trust?"
Sophie hesitated for a second before nodding. "Chloe. She's my dormmate. She's... well, she's never liked Cole, and she's been trying to get me to dump him for months."
"Loop her in tonight," Jack said, pulling a twenty-dollar bill from his wallet and laying it on the table to cover the check. "Tell her everything, and tell her to keep an eye out whenever I'm not around to walk you back."
Later that evening, back in the cramped, fairy-lit dorm room on the east side of campus, Chloe stared at Sophie’s phone screen in dead silence before letting out a low, furious whistle.
"I knew it," Chloe said, tossing the phone gently onto Sophie’s bedspread and crossing her arms. She was the exact opposite of Sophie—tall, sharp-tongued, with messy blonde curls and zero patience for nonsense. "I told you that frat-boy grin of his was fake. Walking into a love hotel on a Tuesday? Trash. Absolute trash."
"Keep your voice down," Sophie whispered, glancing nervously toward the closed dorm door as she pulled her knees up to her chest on her bed.
Chloe’s fierce expression softened immediately. She walked over, sat beside Sophie, and wrapped an arm around her shoulders, pulling her into a tight side hug. "Hey. Don't you dare hide in your own room over a guy like him. You're the best thing that ever happened to Cole, and he threw it away for some two-faced sorority girl."
"Her name is Jessica," Sophie murmured, staring down at her hands. "And... I met her boyfriend today. Jack."
Chloe blinked, leaning back slightly to study Sophie’s face. "Wait. You actually talked to him? How did he take it? Did he punch a wall?"
"No," Sophie said softly, a faint, involuntary warmth blooming in her chest as she thought back to the quiet diner booth and the steady hand resting near hers. "He didn't yell at all. He just... got really quiet. And then he took me off campus so I wouldn't have to cry in front of everyone, bought me food, and made sure I got home safe."
Chloe’s eyes narrowed thoughtfully as she watched the subtle shift in Sophie’s expression—the way the tension seemed to leave her roommate’s voice the moment she said Jack’s name.
"Huh," Chloe said slowly, a protective, calculating glint entering her eyes. "A guy who gets betrayed and his first instinct is to take care of you? Alright. Sounds like Jack's one of the good ones."
Chloe stood up, grabbing her heavy denim jacket off the back of her desk chair and tossing a spare key onto Sophie’s lap.
"Here's the deal," Chloe declared, pointing a finger at Sophie. "From tomorrow morning on, you text me every time you leave class, and I'm walking you to the quad until Jack meets you. Cole wants to play games? Let him try. He's going to wish he never crossed either of you."